Home › Pharmacogenetics guide › Law
Law: who may offer pharmacogenetics? Germany, Austria and Switzerland compared
In Germany, pharmacogenetics is a diagnostic genetic examination (Section 3 No. 7(c) GenDG): only physicians perform it, with information and written consent. In Austria, the Gene Technology Act does not require a medical specialist to order purely pharmacogenetic analyses; according to the Gentechnikbuch, they are not predictive analyses under Section 65(1) Nos. 3 and 4 GTG. Switzerland places pharmacogenetics in the medical context but, besides physicians, also lets pharmacists and – within their field – dentists and chiropractors order it, each under conditions (Arts. 5–8 GUMV). In all three countries, decisions about medication are made by the treating physician.
When the medicine is the trigger: why pharmacogenetics challenges the law
On 4 December 2009, the Austrian Gene Technology Commission put a remarkable idea on record: in pharmacogenetics, the trigger is not the gene but the medicine. A variant that slows an enzyme makes no one ill on its own – only a specific drug at an unsuitable dose can cause problems. The Commission’s example: a heart attack in clopidogrel resistance, because the body does not adequately activate the prodrug clopidogrel (Gentechnikbuch, chapter 5).
Is pharmacogenetics diagnostics, then? Here the laws part ways. Picture a door with a lock. In Germany, only the physician holds the key. In Switzerland, a whole key ring hangs on the hook: for physicians, pharmacists, dentists and chiropractors, each with conditions. In Austria, the Gene Technology Act leaves the door to purely pharmacogenetic testing unlocked. One thing is the same in all three countries: decisions about medication are made by the treating physician. This article gives orientation, not legal advice for your individual case.
Germany: pharmacogenetics is diagnostics – with a physician reservation
The Genetic Diagnostics Act (Gendiagnostikgesetz, GenDG) leaves no doubt. Under Section 3 No. 7(c) GenDG, a diagnostic genetic examination includes an examination that aims to clarify whether genetic traits are present that can influence the effect of a medicinal product. Pharmacogenetics is written into the law – as diagnostics. Clear obligations follow:
- Physician reservation: Only physicians may perform diagnostic genetic examinations (Section 7(1) GenDG). A specialist qualification in human genetics is required only for predictive examinations.
- Lab on assignment: The lab analyzes the sample only on behalf of the responsible physician (Section 7(2)) and only if it has proof of consent (Section 8(1)).
- Consent: explicit and in writing, given to the responsible physician. It also covers whether the result is disclosed or destroyed (Section 8(1)).
- Information beforehand: purpose, type, scope and informative value, with adequate time to reflect (Section 9).
- Counseling afterward: Once the result is in, the responsible physician should offer genetic counseling (Section 10(1)).
- Result via the physician: The lab discloses the result only to the commissioning physician (Section 11(2)), who discloses it to the person examined (Section 11(1)).
For pharmacies: A pharmacogenetic examination under their own responsibility is not possible in Germany, but pharmacists can work with the responsible physician. More in Pharmacogenetics in the pharmacy and Pharmacogenetics in medical practice.
Austria: purely pharmacogenetic testing fits none of the four drawers
The Austrian Gene Technology Act (Gentechnikgesetz, GTG) sorts genetic analyses in humans for medical purposes into four types (Section 65(1) GTG). The strict obligations depend on the type:
| Type | What it is for (Section 65(1)) | What else applies |
|---|---|---|
| Type 1 | Determining an existing disease, preparing a therapy or monitoring its course – based on acquired (somatic) changes | no obligations under Sections 68 and 69 |
| Type 2 | Determining an existing disease based on a germline mutation | specialist information and counseling, consent confirmed in writing (Section 69) |
| Type 3 | Determining a predisposition to a disease or carrier status where prophylaxis or therapy is possible | only in approved facilities and when ordered by a specialist (Section 68(1)), plus Section 69 |
| Type 4 | like type 3, but with no possible prophylaxis or therapy | like type 3 |
Purely pharmacogenetic testing fits none of these drawers: it looks at inherited genes, not acquired changes, and determines neither a disease nor a predisposition. The Gene Technology Commission sees it the same way in the Gentechnikbuch (chapter 5): pharmacogenetic examinations are generally not to be regarded as predictive analyses within the meaning of Section 65(1) Nos. 3 and 4 GTG. Adverse reactions triggered by a medicine are not diseases within the meaning of the GTG.
In practice: For purely pharmacogenetic analyses, the GTG requires neither a specialist order (Section 68(1)) nor specialist information with written confirmation (Section 69). As a principle for genetic analyses for medical purposes, Section 65(1) names the state of science and technology.
Watch out for genes with a double role: If a trait also allows statements about the predisposition to a future hereditary disease, its examination is subject to the rules for predictive analyses, the Gentechnikbuch notes. A 2024 expert opinion for the health ministry (“Neue Entwicklungen bei der Anwendung genetischer Analysen”) gives examples: a pharmacogenetic analysis of the G6PD gene is at the same time an analysis for hereditary G6PD deficiency. And a pharmacogenetically relevant loss-of-function variant in DPYD also means carrier status for hereditary dihydropyrimidine dehydrogenase deficiency. For a panel, this means: check every gene individually.
What could change: The same opinion finds purely pharmacogenetic testing not adequately covered by the GTG. It proposes treating it like type 1 – without specific information and written documentation of consent – and letting every physician who needs the information for therapy order it. This has not been adopted: Sections 65, 68 and 69 GTG are unchanged in the version in force.
And medication? In Austria, prescribing remedies (Heilmittel) is part of practicing medicine (Section 2(2) No. 7 Physicians Act 1998), and independent medical practice is reserved for physicians (Section 3(1)). Anyone offering a pharmacogenetic analysis without a medical license therefore does not recommend stopping, switching or re-dosing a drug, but refers to the treating physician.
Switzerland: medical – but with a whole key ring
Switzerland regulates genetic testing in the Federal Act on Human Genetic Testing (GUMG) and the Ordinance on Human Genetic Testing (GUMV). Pharmacogenetics is clearly medical: Art. 19 GUMG expressly includes tests “to determine the effects of a possible therapy.” The GUMV defines pharmacogenetic tests as genetic tests of characteristics that influence the effect of medicinal products (Art. 2(a)).
As a rule, physicians with a federal qualification in the relevant specialty or in human genetics order tests (“prescribe” in the official translation; Art. 20(1) GUMG). For tests without particular requirements, the Federal Council may widen the circle (Art. 20(3)) – and for pharmacogenetics, it has:
| Who may order | What the GUMV allows | Special features |
|---|---|---|
| Physicians, even without a specialist qualification in the field | pharmacogenetic tests (Art. 5(1)(a)) | conditions of Art. 5(2) |
| Dentists | pharmacogenetic tests in dentistry (Art. 6) | the dentist discloses the result |
| Pharmacists | pharmacogenetic tests (Art. 7) | prior consultation with the prescribing professional for prescription-only medicines; separate consultation area |
| Chiropractors | pharmacogenetic tests in chiropractic (Art. 8) | the chiropractor discloses the result |
All of them must be authorized to practice under their own professional responsibility, and three conditions apply to all (Art. 5(2) GUMV): a specific selection of genetic variants is tested, results of known clinical significance are expected, and preventive or therapeutic measures are available according to current science and practice.
The general rules apply too: free and express consent after adequate information (Arts. 5 and 6 GUMG); the result is communicated by a physician or a specialist the physician authorizes (Art. 26(1)). If a pharmacy orders the test, the pharmacist discloses the result personally – only what relates to its purpose (Art. 7(4) GUMV).
What Switzerland does differently from Germany, Austria and the EU
- More professions than in Germany: There, only the physician performs the examination (Section 7 GenDG); in Switzerland, pharmacists, dentists and chiropractors may order tests too.
- A defined circle instead of an open door: The GTG names no authorized group for purely pharmacogenetic testing. In Switzerland, only the professionals listed in Art. 20 GUMG and Arts. 5 to 8 GUMV may order; everyone else needs such a professional.
- No self-tests: Ready-to-use genetic tests for self-testing may only be supplied for “other” tests outside the medical context (Art. 13 with Art. 31(2) GUMG). Pharmacogenetics is not one of them.
- Advertising with limits: Public advertising for medical genetic tests is banned, except by persons authorized to order them – and theirs must be objective (Art. 14 GUMG, Art. 4(1) GUMV).
- Lab abroad: Prescribing physicians and laboratories may delegate testing to a lab abroad that works to the state of the art, has a quality management system and is authorized in its own country, if the person has consented in writing (Art. 29 GUMG). Clarify your samples’ route to the lab in advance.
Three countries at a glance
| Question | Germany | Austria | Switzerland |
|---|---|---|---|
| Classification | diagnostic genetic examination (Section 3 No. 7(c) GenDG) | per the Gentechnikbuch, not a predictive analysis under Section 65(1) Nos. 3 and 4 GTG | medical context (Art. 19 GUMG) |
| Who orders | physicians only (Section 7(1)) | no specialist order required (Section 68 covers types 3 and 4) | physicians, pharmacists, dentists and chiropractors under conditions (Arts. 5–8 GUMV) |
| Before the analysis | information from the physician, written consent (Sections 8, 9) | Section 69 covers types 2 to 4, not purely pharmacogenetic testing | information, free and express consent (Arts. 5, 6 GUMG) |
| Role of the pharmacy | cooperation with the responsible physician | GTG requires no medical order for purely pharmacogenetic testing; medication stays with the physician (Physicians Act) | may order; prior consultation for prescription-only medicines (Art. 7 GUMV) |
And the EU? The test itself is a medical device
In the EU, a test that the manufacturer intends to provide information to predict treatment response or reactions, or to define or monitor therapeutic measures, is an in vitro diagnostic medical device under Regulation (EU) 2017/746 (Art. 2(2)(e) and (f)). When a genetic test is used in healthcare to improve treatment, member states ensure that the person tested receives relevant information on the nature, significance and implications of the test (Art. 4(1)). Stricter national rules such as the GenDG remain possible (Art. 4(4)).
One rule applies everywhere: medication stays in the physician’s hands
Three countries, three routes – one person at the finish line. A pharmacogenetic result can support a treatment decision. The decision itself – stopping, switching, changing the dose – is made by the treating physician. Switzerland even writes this into its ordinance: if a pharmacy tests the effect of a prescription-only medicine prescribed by another professional, it consults that professional beforehand (Art. 7(2) GUMV). How to explain results clearly is covered in Understanding and communicating results.
Checklist: before you offer pharmacogenetics
- Germany: a physician performs the examination, provides the information, obtains written consent and receives the result.
- Austria: you check every gene in the panel to see whether it also says something about a hereditary disease or carrier status – if so, the rules for predictive analyses apply.
- Switzerland: you are one of the professionals authorized to order tests under Arts. 5 to 8 GUMV, and the conditions of Art. 5(2) are met.
- Swiss pharmacy: prior consultation for prescription-only medicines, separate consultation area.
- Every change to medication goes through the treating physician.
- Consent and data protection are in place – more in Data protection and consent.
Frequently asked questions
Can a pharmacy in Germany offer a pharmacogenetic test?
Does a purely pharmacogenetic analysis in Austria need a physician's referral?
May pharmacists in Switzerland order pharmacogenetic tests?
Is a pharmacogenetic test a medical device?
May I advertise pharmacogenetics to the public in Switzerland?
Related: Data protection and consent · Pharmacogenetics in the pharmacy · Who may offer genetic tests?
Pharmacogenetics in your practice or pharmacy?
Tell us about your setting – we will show you how the offer can work for you.
Request a project →Offer for physiciansNote: This guide is general information for businesses and professionals and does not replace medical or legal advice. The genetic traits determined in a genetic analysis are well documented (each gene included is backed by at least three independent studies); recommendations derived from them are logical conclusions, not scientifically proven. Pharmacogenetic results do not replace a medical decision: any change to medication is made only by the treating physician. Regulations can change; errors and changes excepted.
